Pizzas

Our pizzas are served on johnny’s fresh thin crust and covered with his homemade pizza sauce. Substitute any 12” pizza with a cauliflower crust for an additional cost.

Logan Pizza

Cheese.

$9.00

One Topping Pizza

$10.00

Combination Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, and mushrooms.

$13.00

Veggie Pizza

Black olives, green olives, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions.

$13.00

Signature Pizzas

Our pizzas are served on johnny’s fresh thin crust and covered with his homemade pizza sauce. Substitute any 12” pizza with a cauliflower crust for an additional cost.

BBQ Chicken Pizza

BBQ sauce and grilled chicken.

$14.00

Taco Pizza

Refried beans, salsa, taco meat, lettuce, and taco chips.

$14.00

Meat Lovers Pizza

Pepperoni, capicola, sausage, and hamburger.

$14.00

The Big Saucy Pizza

Your choice of sweet chili, bourbon, or buffalo sauce with grilled chicken.

$14.00

Chicken Alfredo Pizza

Alfredo sauce and grilled chicken.

$14.00

Timmy Special Pizza

Grinder meat, capicola, sausage, and roasted peppers.

$14.00

Starters

Onion Rings

Thinly sliced, lightly seasoned onion rings are fried to perfection.

$10.00

Cheese Fries

Warm nacho cheese served over our crispy crinkle fries.

$6.00

Cheese Sticks

Six breaded mozzarella sticks fried to a golden brown finish. Served with Johnny’s homemade pasta sauce.

$8.00

Boneless Wings

Boneless chicken wings served with your choice of sauce: Sweet Chili, Buffalo, Bourbon, or BBQ.

$10.00

Fried Portobella Mushrooms

Breaded mushrooms fried to a crisp finish.

$11.00

Garlic Bread

Four pieces of buttered bread sprinkled with garlic and toasted. Served with Johnny’s homemade pasta sauce. Add cheese for an additional cost.

$7.00

Cheesy Stadium Sticks

12” pizza crust topped with cheese, butter, herbs and spices. Served with a side of Johnny’s homemade pasta sauce or ranch.

$10.00

Pretzel Bites

Warm bite size pretzel balls served with a side of warm queso.

$10.00

Cheese Curds

Wisconsin cheese curds deep fried to a golden brown, served with a side of ranch

$9.00

Ravioli

Homemade ravioli with your choice of cheese or meat filling, served with a side of Johnny’s homemade pasta sauce

$8.00

Pickle Chips

Crinkle cut dill pickle chips hand breaded and fried. Served with a side of ranch dressing

$9.00

Salads

Served with your choice of dressing: ranch, low fat ranch, Italian, French, honey mustard, bleu cheese,or creamy parmesan.

Chicken Salad

Fresh romain lettuce topped with mozzarella cheese and served with your choice of breaded or grilled chicken.

$11.00

Dinner Salad

Fresh romain lettuce topped with pepperoni and mozzarella cheese.

$5.00

Veggie Salad

Fresh romain lettuce topped with mozzarella cheese along with black and green olives, onions, mushrooms, and green peppers.

$11.00

Regular Sides

French Fries

Our delicious French fries are deep-fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!

$2.00

Cottage Cheese

$2.00

Chips & Cookie

$2.00

Premium Sides

Creamy Macaroni

$5.00

Side Onion Rings

Thinly sliced, lightly seasoned onion rings are fried to perfection.

$5.00

Side Dinner Salad

Fresh romain lettuce topped with pepperoni and mozzarella cheese.

$5.00

Baskets

All sandwiches are served with your choice of a regular side. Upgrade to a Premium side for an additional charge.

Breaded Tenderloin Sandwich

A hand-breaded tenderloin fried golden and served on a freshly toasted bun.

$12.00

Grinder

Ground up Italian sausage marinated in Johnny’s homemade pasta sauce. Served on a toasted hoagie and topped with mozzarella cheese.

$11.00

Italian Sausage Sandwich

Graziano sausage patty grilled and served on a toasted Italian bread with Johnny’s homemade pasta sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$11.00

Philly Sandwich

Your choice of chicken or beef served on a hoagie bun with cream cheese and baked with grilled onions, sweet peppers, and mozzarella cheese.

$11.00

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

A breaded chicken breast fried and served on an Italian bread covered with mozzarella cheese and Johnny’s homemade pasta sauce.

$12.00

Capicola Sandwich

An Italian spiced ham grilled and seasoned. Served on a hoagie bun basted with Johnny’s homemade pasta sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$11.00

Chicken Sandwich

Your choice of a breaded or grilled chicken breast served on a toasted bun. Smother it in your favorite wing sauce for an additional cost.

$11.00

Chicken Strips

Three breaded chicken strips fried crispy and golden. Served with your choice of ranch, BBQ, or honey mustard

$10.00

Burgers

All hamburgers are served on a freshly toasted bun with lettuce, onion, pickle, ketchup & mustard along with your choice of a regular side. Upgrade to a Premium side for and additonal cost.

Hamburger

Burger grilled to perfection on our flat top grill, served on a toasted bun. Add cheese for an additional cost.

$11.00

Mushroom Swiss Burger

Hamburger patty topped with grilled mushrooms and melted Swiss cheese.

$13.00

Pizza Burger

Hamburger patty topped with grinder meat, pizza sauce, and mozzarella cheese. Served on a toasted bun.

$14.00

Western Burger

Hamburger patty grilled to perfection and covered with fried onion rings and mozzarella cheese. To top it off, we cover it with Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ Sauce.

$13.00

Breakfast Burger

Hamburger patty topped with a fried egg and bacon, and covered with melted American cheese.

$13.00

Pasta

All pastas are served with your choice of meat sauce or meatballs & two slices of garlic bread.

Mostaccioli

Penne noodles covered with Johnny's homemade pasta sauce.

$11.00

Spaghetti

Spaghetti noodles topped with Johnny's homemade pasta sauce. Make it a Casserole for an additional cost.

$11.00

Cavatelli

Penne noodles baked with Johnny’s homemade pasta sauce and mozzarella cheese melted over top.

$12.00

Fettuccine

Fettuccini noodles covered with a creamy alfredo sauce. Add grilled chicken for an additional cost.

$12.00

Chicken Parmesan

Topped with Johnny’s homemade pasta sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$13.00

Creamy Macaroni

Macaroni noodles served in a thick and creamy cheese sauce. Add grinder meat, grilled or breaded chicken for an additional cost.

$11.00

Kids

For kids 12 & under. Comes with your choice of a regular side (excluding Kid’s Mostaccioli)

Kid's Hamburger

A kid’s sized hamburger patty grilled on our flat top grill, served on a toasted bun. Add cheese for an additional cost.

$6.00

Kid's Chicken Strips

Two breaded chicken strips fried to a golden brown finish. Served with your choice of ranch, BBQ, or Honey Mustard.

$6.00

Kid's Grilled Cheese

Two pieces of bread lightly buttered and grilled with two slices of American cheese sandwiched in the middle.

$6.00

Kid's Mostaccioli

Penne noodles served with one meatball and one slice of garlic bread.

$6.00

Kid's Creamy Macaroni

Macaroni noodles served in a thick and creamy cheese sauce.

$6.00

Beverages

Soda

$1.00

Your Order

No address

Johnny & Mike's Pizza

Enjoy Carlisle's best pizzas at some of the top pizza restaurants in the area. Johnny & Mike's Pizza is one of the most popular in Carlisle. Try their pizza, and you'll soon see why. Try some of Carlisle's best dishes at independent pizzerias in the city. Find new favorites and get a taste of what Carlisle has to offer. You can't say you've been to Johnny & Mike's Pizza until you've tried Logan Pizza. This classic local favorite is what this establishment is known for. Add french fries to your pizza for a more satisfying meal. It's a great addition to any pizza from Johnny & Mike's Pizza. Johnny & Mike's Pizza has been a Slice partner since 2020. They've been serving the local community for a while now, so you can rely on them providing great pizza. Call ahead and get curbside pickup at Johnny & Mike's Pizza. It's never been easier to get hot, fresh pizza to go. You can pay by credit card at Johnny & Mike's Pizza. That makes it easy to get your pizza as quickly as possible. Catch up with Johnny & Mike's Pizza on social media.

Get Directions

Full Hours

order ahead